Mariska Hargitay Once Shared the ‘Law & Order SVU’ Episode More Terrifying Than ‘Surrender Benson’

Mariska Hargitay’s character, Olivia Benson, has endured numerous harrowing experiences on Law & Order: SVU, but one episode stands out as particularly challenging: “Surrender Benson.” In this intense episode, Benson is held captive by the villainous William Lewis, a role that left Hargitay deeply shaken despite the controlled filming environment.

“It was, without a doubt, the most difficult episode I ever shot in 15 years, and it was unlike anything I’ve ever done,” Hargitay revealed to Today. “I have to tell you, after 15 years, to be nervous and scared and excited to go to work — it’s a pretty great thing.”

Facing New Horrors in “Townhouse Incident”

Years later, Hargitay would face a similar ordeal in the episode “Townhouse Incident,” where Olivia Benson is once again taken hostage, this time by the unpredictable Joe Utley. Despite her previous experience, Hargitay approached this episode with even greater apprehension than “Surrender Benson.”

“To be honest, I probably approached it with a bit more dread than the Lewis episode because I knew what I felt like after that one,” Hargitay told The Hollywood Reporter. “At the same time, I was excited to dig in deeper, and do it differently, to hit different notes and depths. My friends who are marathoners tell me the same thing: right after they finish, they say never again, but then a few days later, they’re signing up for the next one.”

A More Unpredictable Threat

Hargitay felt that Joe Utley was a more erratic and unpredictable threat compared to William Lewis, which significantly affected Benson’s response. “Lewis was calculated, in control, and Joe is very much out of control. That can’t help but affect Benson’s response. She’s more in the position of hostage negotiator this time, and she has other players in the situation to deal with.”

A Mother’s Urgency

Adding a unique layer to the “Townhouse Incident” was Benson’s new role as a mother, having legally adopted her son Noah. This maternal responsibility amplified the stakes and urgency of the situation.

“Everything she says, every reaction she has is new and carries more weight,” Hargitay explained. “Everything matters more, everything matters differently. As an actor, it’s always great to know that the stakes have gone up. It always feels like an invitation to dig deeper, to dig differently, to dig into even more uncomfortable places.”

A Character’s Evolution

Since “Surrender Benson,” Olivia Benson has grown significantly, advancing in her career and personal life. The SVU team was eager to explore how this development would influence her handling of another hostage situation.

“The detectives who actually do this job out in the real world don’t have control over how many times they encounter this kind of danger,” Hargitay said. “But we thought it would be interesting to have the chance to explore how Benson would approach a hostage situation at this point in her arc. Here’s this person who’s constantly having to prove her strength — to higher-ups, to herself — and her guard is down for one moment, and she’s in a very bad situation. That’s a really compelling thing for a character to have to metabolize.”

Conclusion

Mariska Hargitay’s portrayal of Olivia Benson continues to captivate audiences, especially in episodes that push her character to the limits. “Townhouse Incident” not only revisited the intense drama of “Surrender Benson” but also showcased the profound evolution of a beloved character. Through these trials, Law & Order: SVU remains a testament to powerful storytelling and character development, keeping viewers on the edge of their seats year after year.